Read an Excerpt
The Prologue and Chapter One — free to read.
A novel of moral consequence, identity, and the cost of a single decision.
Prologue
Maxwell Beaumont read the article twice. It appeared in the New York Times Arts section, dated Sunday, February 7, 1999. He sat alone in the sunroom of his East Hampton estate, a glass of Bordeaux untouched beside him. Beyond the wraparound porch and clipped boxwoods, the Atlantic lay flat beneath a low, gunmetal sky. The horizon blurred into haze, sea and air nearly indistinguishable.
The headline stretched across the upper fold: "Whispers of a Cézanne: ICAR Flags Inquiry on Long-Missing Masterpiece."
Beneath it, a photograph. A tall, narrow man stood beside a reproduction of Bouilloire et Fruits — the Cézanne that once hung in Maxwell's study. His suit was dark. His posture precise. Hands at his sides, military straight. His gaze steady.
"James Remington, founder of the International Commission for Art Recovery (ICAR), beside a reproduction of the Cézanne recently flagged through a confidential auction-house inquiry."
The article gave no names. No location. Only that, on January 18th, a London attorney had quietly contacted Sotheby's to ask whether a certain client could verify provenance on a privately held Cézanne. Sotheby's, following protocol, submitted the inquiry to ICAR's stolen-art registry. The painting had not surfaced. But the question alone was enough.
Maxwell exhaled slowly and refolded the paper along its crease. It had been more than twenty years since the theft — seven paintings taken in one night from his house in Stockbridge: two Jansems, two Soutines, a de Vlaminck, an Utrillo. And the Cézanne. All had belonged to his parents, Harry and Rose. A collection built over decades. Each piece a thread in the family tapestry. But Bouilloire et Fruits had been their treasure, passed to Maxwell not as a gift but as a trust.
Maxwell Beaumont didn't come from money the way most people said it — he came from it like a cathedral came from stone. His father Harry was a pediatrician who met Rose Mason in Paris just after the war. She was top of her class at Columbia, already fluent in French, already too sharp for the men around her. What bonded them wasn't medicine. It was art. Long afternoons in Montparnasse galleries. Quiet arguments about Caillebotte and Chagall. When they came home to Manhattan they brought with them a gallery's worth of Parisian canvases and a belief that beauty — not just medicine — could save a life.
They didn't just collect. They befriended painters, curators, gallerists. Summers weren't spent at the Cape. They went to Florence for light, to Paris for color, to Amsterdam for structure. While other kids chased fireflies, Maxwell was standing in a gallery beside his father being told to look closely — closer still — until the pitcher in the still life seemed to move.
Harry died without ceremony — there one evening, gone by morning. Rose gathered the children and told them their father had left instructions. Each of them would choose one painting. Something to remember us by, he'd written, tucked behind a photograph on his desk. When Rose turned to Maxwell, she didn't need to ask.
"Bouilloire et Fruits," he said, the French rolling off his tongue like he'd been born to it.
It wasn't the most expensive. Or the rarest. But it had hung in Harry's study for as long as Maxwell could remember — a pewter jug, a bowl of fruit, a white cloth folded with care. It wasn't just a painting. It was his father's presence, made permanent.
At the Stockbridge estate, Maxwell hung the Cézanne in his study, directly across from the desk. He never spoke about the choice, but he always pointed it out to guests — quietly, deliberately — like sharing a secret he never quite stopped marveling at. Morning light hit it through the eastern window, soft and slanted, catching the folds in the white cloth and the pewter jug like breath on silver. Maxwell would sit for hours at that desk, letters spread before him, pen in hand, eyes drifting up and resting there — on the one thing that never moved, never left, and never let him forget where he came from.
The others mattered. But the Cézanne was blood.
He rubbed his temple, then reached for the phone and dialed London.
"Get me James Remington," he said. "Tell him I'm retaining him. Whatever his fee."
Continue reading in Chapter One — where the theft begins.
Chapter One
Dante Caruso's '71 Chevy wheezed its way up Route 102, tailpipe coughing, trunk shimmying like it had a body in the back. The dashboard clock still blinked 3:17 — a lie it'd been telling for months — but he thumped it anyway with a thick, calloused knuckle. Nothing. The A/C had long since given up. The vinyl bench seat was split and hot, the vents pushing warm air that smelled like old cigarettes and sawdust. From the dash, WBCN crackled through the speakers, Warren Zevon's new single drifting in from Boston — "Lawyers, Guns and Money." The right speaker buzzed, cutting in and out like it was chewing through the wires.
Beside him, Terry Wallace slouched low in the passenger seat, one boot propped on the dash, rolling a joint on something he'd dug out of the glove box. He was a master at it — pinching the stems and coaxing the seeds down with his fingertip until they gathered neat at the bottom, the way fat skims off ground meat when it cooks. When he was done, he tipped the seeds off onto the floorboard, then lifted the paper, rolled it tight, and sealed it with a slow lick. His denim vest was streaked with chain grease, and the patch on the chest read HONDA in faded red thread. He talked about bikes more than women — owned two, wrecked one, and swore he could rebuild the other once he got the money. Terry had the rare gift of being laid-back and difficult all at once.
Caruso glanced over. Then looked again. "Give me that." Wallace didn't move. "What's your problem?" Caruso leaned across and took it from him. "What are you, a fuckin' idiot?" He brushed it clean with his thumb and smoothed it flat against the wheel.
The sketch was still there — two rooms circled, dining room and foyer, with a note scrawled beneath them: key under ceramic frog — back patio. He flipped it over. The phone number was still legible in thick black ink: (516) 324-6897. He folded it once and slipped it into his shirt pocket.
Wallace watched him for a beat. "That's your map? Christ, I've seen better ones in kids' cereal boxes."
Caruso didn't answer. Just tightened his grip on the wheel.
They passed the weathered green sign on the side of the road: ENTERING STOCKBRIDGE – EST. 1739.
The houses changed first — white clapboard, stone chimneys, manicured lawns trimmed like showroom rugs. Hydrangeas bloomed in neat bursts, blue and pink and unnaturally bright. The whole town looked like it had been arranged for a postcard.
"Jesus," Wallace muttered, flicking ash out the window. "People actually live like this?"
They pulled into the gravel lot beside the General Store — used to be Alice's Restaurant, from that Arlo Guthrie song. The hand-painted sign still hung near the porch, though the windows were filled now with American flags and garden gnomes. Caruso parked crooked, his front tire resting against a faded parking bumper.
He reached into his shirt pocket and pulled out the folded card. He stepped down onto the gravel, the truck groaning under his weight, and glanced at the phone booth across the lot — glass smudged, frame sweating in the heat.
"Go grab me a Coke," he said. Wallace didn't move. "What am I, your fuckin' errand boy?" "Just do it," Caruso said, already walking toward the booth. "I need to make the call."
Wallace groaned, slid out of the passenger seat, and slammed the door harder than he needed to.
The phone booth felt like a greenhouse — glass fogged, metal hot enough to brand your elbow if you weren't careful. He dropped in a dime, dialed with his thick finger, and waited.
One ring. Two. Three.
"Hello?" Danny.
"Still good?" Caruso asked.
"Yeah," Danny said. "Everything's clear." A pause. "And after this," Danny added, "we're square, right?"
Caruso stared through the smudged glass at nothing in particular. "Yeah. We're square."
Because what Danny owed him — a couple grand, maybe — wasn't even close to what Caruso owed the people above him. He wasn't late on a credit card. He was late on men in Boston who didn't send reminders. You missed a payment, they came to your door. And they never came alone.
He hung up, wiped his palm on his jeans, and stepped out into the heat just as Wallace came out of the store holding a sweating can of soda. He tossed it underhand, and Caruso caught it without looking.
"Tell me that's not a goddamn Tab," Caruso said.
"It's cold." Wallace shrugged. "What more do you want?"
Caruso opened the can, took a sip, and grimaced. "Remind me to kill you later."
Wallace nodded toward the phone booth. "You trust the kid?"
"No." Caruso took another swallow and wiped his mouth with the back of his hand. "Kid shows up at a house party in Pittsfield, people clapping him on the back like he's a war hero. I ask for my money. He says he doesn't have it. So I walk him out back — threw him against the wall and reminded him what that means. Then he comes up with this map." He tapped the folded card in his shirt pocket. "Says there's six paintings, no alarms, no cameras. That they're worth more than what he owes. Kid's not smart, but he's scared." He looked across the lot. "That's enough."
Wallace studied the tree line. "And if he's wrong?"
Caruso crushed the can in one hand. "Why would he lie to me? He knows where I can find him."
They drove the last few miles in silence. Dusk was folding in now — soft and low, bleeding through the trees. Just past the turnoff for Bullard Woods, Caruso veered onto a dirt cutaway that ran behind a thick patch of pines. No lights. No pedestrians. Just the kind of cover a job like this needed.
He circled to the back of the car and popped the trunk. Inside were gloves, flashlights, and two lengths of PVC tubing — scraps from an old plumbing job. Nothing fancy. Just enough to keep the canvases from getting bent. He grabbed the gear without a word, slipped the pistol into the back of his waistband, grip up, and shut the trunk. Then the two of them made their way toward the trees.
The path through the woods curved along a natural ridge behind the estate, narrow and overgrown. Moonlight filtered through the canopy in patches, bright enough that they kept moving. Wallace took the lead, moving fast and low, flashlight in hand, beam tight to the ground. He stepped over roots, ducked under limbs, kept a steady pace like this wasn't his first break-in.
Caruso lagged behind. The brush tugged at his jacket, and his breath came shorter than he liked. His boots sank into the soft ground with every step. He planted a hand on a tree and paused for half a second, catching it. "Jesus," he muttered. "Should've parked closer."
Wallace didn't slow down. "Or maybe lose a little weight."
As they cut through the trees, rooftops began to appear — wide, sloping, and silent. One house after another, each one bigger than the last. Landscaped lawns, tiered decks, chimneys tall enough to anchor weathervanes. Caruso muttered under his breath. "Christ. Must be nice."
At the edge of the clearing, the house came into view — dark, still, the kind of still that made his shoulders tighten. A single porch light glowed above the back patio. The rest of the place was drowned in shadow.
They moved quiet now. Wallace stayed a step ahead, eyes scanning the yard, boots silent on the flagstone. The ceramic frog sat under a bed of hydrangeas, just like the kid said. Caruso spotted it first. He crouched, lifted it, and held up the key. Neither of them said a word.
Wallace turned to Caruso. The moment hung there.
"Stick to the plan," Caruso said, catching his breath. "I get the three in the dining room. You get the three in the foyer. Grab, roll, and go."
He slid the key into the lock and turned it. The bolt gave with a soft click. He eased the door open, and they stepped into the darkened rear hallway — just off the kitchen. The air was still, cool, and smelled faintly of lemon polish and old money — that mix of waxed wood, paper, and something floral no one could name.
They moved quietly down the main corridor. Thick runner rug. Crown molding. A house that had been dressed to impress.
Ahead, the hallway opened up into the front foyer. To the right, just before it, a wide archway led into the dining room — walls lined with spotlit art, just like the kid said. Caruso stopped at the dining room entrance. Wallace kept going, a finger raised in acknowledgment. No words. Just the soft rhythm of boot soles on carpet as they peeled off in separate directions.
Caruso steadied himself, reached up, and eased the first frame off the wall. The spotlight above it gave off a faint hum, casting a cone of light over the canvas. He pulled the box cutter from his pocket and flicked the blade out with a practiced snap. One edge. Then another. He worked quick and careful, slicing clean lines along all four sides. The canvas peeled away smooth.
Second one — same size, similar weight. He worked the edges patient, peeled it clean, rolled it up. The third was trickier — thick oils, heavy brushwork. The blade caught on a ridge and snagged. "Shit," he muttered. He adjusted, angling the blade lower, slicing beneath the texture without tearing. It came free. Rolled stiff, but it fit. Barely. He snapped the cap shut and wiped his hands on his jeans.
Wallace made quick work of the foyer — blade out, hands steady, canvas rolling tight. As he turned back down the corridor, something caught his eye. A door — set off to the side — slightly ajar. He slowed. The room beyond was dark. Just a sliver of wood-paneled wall visible through the gap.
Wallace hesitated. One beat. Two.
Then the grandfather clock in the foyer struck the hour.
The first chime rang through the house, louder than it had any right to be. Wallace flinched. The second followed. Then the third. Caruso froze in the corridor, his hand dropping instinctively to the pistol at his waistband. Neither of them moved.
Then it stopped. The house returned to its silence.
Caruso didn't wait. He turned for the back door, easing it shut behind him as he stepped onto the patio. He slung the PVC tube over one shoulder and checked his watch, then glanced back at the door. Too long. Wallace still hadn't shown, and Caruso shifted his weight uneasily, eyes sweeping the yard and the dark beyond.
Finally, the door creaked open. Wallace stepped out, breathing a little harder than he should've been.
"What the hell took you?" Caruso asked.
Wallace didn't answer. Pulled the door shut, locked it, and dropped the key back under the ceramic frog. "Let's move."
They slipped into the trees and started down the hill. At the bottom, the Chevy sat where they'd left it — dented, dirty, and still. Caruso popped the trunk.
"Let me see 'em," he said.
Wallace handed over his tube. Caruso reached in and pulled out the first canvas. Then another. Then a third.
A fourth canvas slipped from the tube. He stopped, the air between them stretching thin as he held it up to see.
"What the hell's this?"
"It was in an office off the hallway. Looked expensive — big gold frame, its own little light shining on it. Thought it had to be worth something."
"You weren't supposed to go in there."
Wallace hesitated, just long enough to feel stupid for hesitating at all. "The door was open. It was lit up — like it was begging me to take it." He grinned. "I'm a thief, remember?"
Caruso unrolled the canvas across the lip of the trunk. It curled at the edges, wouldn't lie flat. A kettle. Some fruit. A sagging white cloth.
Caruso stared at it for a beat, then shook his head. "Looks like a Fruit of the Loom ad. Who the hell pays for this shit?" He didn't hand it back. Just rolled it tight, slid it into the PVC tube with the others, and shut the trunk.
"You're a goddamn idiot," he muttered.
Wallace yanked open the passenger door. "You'll thank me someday," he said, winking as he climbed in.
"I'm definitely killing you later."
The Chevy wheezed to life. Taillights blinked like broken signals as they disappeared into the dark. Stockbridge faded behind them — polished, perfect, and about to wake up missing something.
The novel continues — following the paintings across decades, and the man who kept them.
Get notified when it publishes About the Author